Current:Home > NewsHistorian on Trump indictment: "The most important criminal trial in American history"-InfoLens
Historian on Trump indictment: "The most important criminal trial in American history"
View Date:2024-12-23 18:53:02
Our commentary comes from Princeton University history professor Julian Zelizer, editor of the book, "The Presidency of Donald J. Trump: A First Historical Assessment."
The new indictment of former President Donald Trump constitutes a historic turning point. This promises to be the most important criminal trial in American history.
Under special counsel Jack Smith, the Department of Justice has boldly declared that accountability is essential to our democracy.
Smith's damning indictment has charged Trump with four counts of attempting to overturn the 2020 election. Trump's actions threatened the peaceful transfer of power, a process that separates us from non-democratic countries.
- Trump indicted by grand jury in special counsel Jack Smith's Jan. 6 investigation
- Read the full Department of Justice indictment of Donald J. Trump
- What to know about Trump's 3 indictments, 4 criminal investigations
Through a concerted effort that culminated with a violent mob storming Capitol Hill, Trump rejected the integral norm undergirding a stable democratic system, namely that losers must accept legitimate defeats. Even President Richard Nixon, who resigned in disgrace as a result of the Watergate scandal, understood this to be true.
With this indictment, the Department of Justice has broken with the controversial precedent established by President Gerald Ford in 1974, when he pardoned Nixon for any crimes that he might have committed. The impeachment process offered the possibility of holding Nixon accountable; Ford let the opportunity pass by.
After almost a decade of Americans fighting over race, war and Watergate, Ford concluded it was more important to "heal" the nation by pardoning Nixon than allowing a lengthy legal trial to proceed. Looking directly into the cameras, Ford warned Americans that if a trial took place, "Ugly passions would again be aroused, and our people would again be polarized in their opinions, and the credibility of our free institutions of government would again be challenged at home and abroad."
But the pardon did not heal the nation. We grew more divided. Many furious Americans claimed that Ford had been part of a corrupt deal. When Ford traveled to North Carolina, he arrived to see placards that asked: "Is Nixon Above the Law??"
His approval ratings plummeted.
- Ford's pardon still controversial ("Face the Nation")
More pertinent, Ford entrenched a damaging norm that became part of our nostalgia, pushing leaders away from taking legal action against elected officials who abused their power.
Presidents have continued to feel imperial.
Trump tested Ford's proposition more than any president since Nixon – and Biden's Department of Justice has responded that Ford was wrong.
We must preserve key guardrails that prevent the abuse of presidential power. If our leaders violate sacrosanct democratic principles, they will be held accountable regardless of the political fallout.
For more info:
- "The Presidency of Donald J. Trump: A First Historical Assessment," edited by Julian E. Zelizer (Princeton University Press), in Hardcover, Trade Paperback and eBook formats, available via Amazon, Barnes & Noble and Bookshop.org
- Julian Zelizer, professor of history and public affairs, Princeton University
Story produced by Jay Kernis. Editor: Maria Barrow.
See also:
- Which 2024 Republican candidates would pardon Trump if they won the presidency? Here's what they're saying.
- Former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson says GOP talk of potential Trump pardon is "inappropriate" ("Face the Nation")
- Can a president pardon himself?
- In:
- Donald Trump
- Jack Smith
veryGood! (25735)
Related
- Here's what 3 toys were inducted into the National Toy Hall of Fame this year
- One Extraordinary (Olympic) Photo: Vadim Ghirda captures the sunset framed by the Arc de Triomphe
- Here’s Why Blake Lively Doesn’t Use Conditioner—And How Her Blake Brown Products Can Give You Iconic Hair
- Navy football's Chreign LaFond learns his sister, Thea, won 2024 Paris Olympics gold medal: Watch
- Catholic bishops urged to boldly share church teachings — even unpopular ones
- Tropical Glaciers in the Andes Are the Smallest They’ve Been in 11,700 Years
- Noah Lyles gets second in a surprising 100m opening heat at Olympics
- There's good reason to root for the South Koreans to medal in Olympic men's golf
- Georgia public universities and colleges see enrollment rise by 6%
- Woman's body found with no legs in California waterway, coroner asks public to help ID
Ranking
- Trump ally Steve Bannon blasts ‘lawfare’ as he faces New York trial after federal prison stint
- Watch these Oklahoma Police officers respond to a horse stuck in a swimming pool
- The 20 Best Amazon Fashion Deals Right Now: $7.40 Shorts, $8.50 Tank Tops, $13 Maxi Dresses & More
- Monday through Friday, business casual reigns in US offices. Here's how to make it work.
- Mike Tyson emerges as heavyweight champ among product pitchmen before Jake Paul fight
- Street artists use their art to express their feelings about Paris Olympics
- 2 Georgia National Guard soldiers die in separate noncombat incidents in Iraq
- U.S. defense secretary rejects plea deal for 9/11 mastermind, puts death penalty back on table
Recommendation
-
Brian Austin Green Shares Message to Sharna Burgess Amid Ex Megan Fox's Baby News
-
Mark Kelly may be Kamala Harris' VP pick: What that would mean for Americans
-
Olympics 2024: Pole Vaulter Anthony Ammirati's Manhood Knocks Him Out of Competition
-
Chase Budinger, Miles Evans win lucky loser volleyball match. Next up: Reigning Olympic champs
-
Is Kyle Richards Finally Ready to File for Divorce From Mauricio Umansky? She Says...
-
Ohio is expected to launch recreational marijuana sales next week
-
How US women turned their fortunes in Olympic 3x3 basketball: 'Effing wanting it more'
-
Katie Ledecky makes Olympic history again, winning 800m freestyle gold for fourth time